Tuesday 1 November 2011

Cue for Treason: Question V

Question Number V:


5. Students often have difficulty relating to Shakespeare or other writers from the past. However, they do not have as much trouble relating to characters that are set in the past, as in historical fiction. Choose one of the main characters, Peter, Kit, Sir Phillip or another, and persuade the audience that as characters we can still relate to them today. You may want to start with their characteristics and then think of present day examples that are similar.

      Sir Phillip will be the character that I will be analyzing today. Sir Phillip is the landlord in Cumberland from the book Cue for Treason. He was that guy that had everything, but also wanted everything. By this, I mean that he was very rich. He inherited estate from his grandfather. He also owned lots of land, and lived in a large mansion, as he was part of the noble class. Even though he had much more than he needed, he still wanted more. He charged people living on his land much more than what they always payed, trying to make more money. He built a wall around citizens' land forcefully, claiming that it was all his, even though it wasn't. He even planned to try to assassinate the Queen, so that he could obtain more power.

     Sir Phillip is a greedy, shallow, and selfish person. He abused his power by taking people's land forcefully and raising land rent rates, just for more money. Even though we see him as the very bad, mean, greedy antagonist, we aren't that different from him. It isn't ALL of Sir Phillip's fault for being greedy. It's in our nature. As humans, we are all greedy. We want more, even when we have what we need. As a Canadian citizen, I am very thankful for having a roof over my head, healthy water and food, a car, a computer, and much more many things that would take too long to list. I have all I need! No, I have more than I need! But I still complain and always want more and more things. African children would give up everything just to have fresh water. American girls would give up everything to meet Justin Bieber. See the difference? We are no different from Sir Phillip Morton!


Kronos, or Cronus (from Ancient Greek Myths), was the leader and the youngest of the first generation of Titans, descendant of Gaia and Uranus. He, in my opinion, relates to Sir Phillip Morton. Kronos envied Uranus' power, as Uranus was the ruler of the universe. From this envy, greed took over Kronos. He [Kronos] got a great stone sickle, and cut Uranus into a thousand pieces, so that Kronos could rule the universe.

   A present day example would be the warlords in Somalia. As Somalia is in a devastating famine, international aid is mandatory. But all humanitarian aid sent to Somalia is either rejected, taken, or stolen by the warlords, just for their gain, and not thinking about all the dying Somalians.

    Even if it seems like Sir Phillip is not like us, or related to us in anyway, in the end, we can relate to him in many ways.

3 comments:

  1. a great dose of reality as mentioned about those who would give the world for some water, however i disagree with the fact that we are all like sir phillip. People are unique. Anybody can be kind or mean, and sir phillip was just based around 1 idea. There are still PLENTY of people who are trying to help and make a difference in the world, this is why human nature is not to be greedy, its to survive, and we don't react to danger or others suffering unless its right in our face. However, its human error, (usually based on your environment)to create greed. Great job though, and good argument as well as brining in Somalia.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Great job with the Kronos example. I kind of disagree with you on the point you made about all humans being greedy because there are nice and kind people in the world.

    Also, like what Ms. Lees mentioned in class, try to avoid the "I" voice, you used it throughout your essay. For example, "I am very thankful for having a roof over my head, healthy water and food, a car, a computer, and much more many things that would take too long to list. I have all I need! No, I have more than I need!"

    Lastly, your opening sentance sounds like "today I will be talking about." It might of been better to just erase that line.

    ReplyDelete